## Turbo Talk => General Discussion => Topic started by: nadsab on November 28, 2012, 06:29:16 AM

Post by: nadsab on November 28, 2012, 06:29:16 AM
I would like to try making my own threads on a rod.

The rod would have left hand threads on one end, and RH threads on the other, and would meet at center of rod. Like the kind of adjustment rod that is commonly found in a Bow Compass.

The type of thread, and the pitch does not matter, I just want to make generic threads on a rod for illustration purposes.

I assume I will have to draw two elliptical circles around the rod at equal opposite angles to each other, and then somehow copy and paste the ellipses along the length of the rod and then then increase like thickness so the threads will show.

Whats the best method or technique to do this in Deluxe 19?
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Carroll P on November 28, 2012, 07:18:52 AM
I just drew a line however long you want the rod. Then drew a V where the dia of the rod is to be. Then I drew a cyl the length of the line. Then went to 3d revolve and in propertys set up the number of coils I wanted. Then set up the spiral pitch I wanted. (in this case 1/16in) then clicked counter clockwise. Then selected the V then what ever end you wanted it to start on clicked on the line. It then should put your threads on in that direction. Then select V again and change in revolve options the counterclock wise direction select opposite end of the line it then should put the threads on the other end. I hope this is about what you want. Carroll
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: littleman on December 02, 2012, 08:39:18 AM
Are you doing 2d or 3d?
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Carroll P on December 03, 2012, 05:53:30 AM
The V is drawen as a 2d object and rotated around a cylinder with the 3d revolve tool. Carroll
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 03, 2012, 12:23:35 PM
Thanks so much Carroll, I will check it out and try to duplicate it from scratch and practice!

3D littleman.
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 03, 2012, 12:34:31 PM
I just drew a line however long you want the rod. Then drew a V where the dia of the rod is to be. Then I drew a cyl the length of the line.

I understand the later stuff but not really sure how you set this up.  Is the V connected to the line?  Or the Cylinder?  Is the vertex of the V on one of the ends of the line?  Is the line the center axis of the rod?
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: John R on December 03, 2012, 02:24:16 PM
Something like this. A closed polyline, revolved around the perimeter of a cylinder. Open the Properties for the revolved object and enter a value for "Spiral Pitch". The "Number of Coils" field will become available and enter how many coils you require. 3D Add the two objects together. Terrible picture, but hopefully you get the idea.
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 03, 2012, 03:27:15 PM
I think I get it, the tip of the V has to be pointing in towards the centerline?
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 09, 2012, 02:21:45 PM
I was just wondering - is there a way to feather the ends of threads?  In other words, where the threads start and end on any screw, they are feathered towards the OD of the shaft when they start and end - fade into the metal - don't know what they call that....
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 09, 2012, 02:57:21 PM
I was just wondering - is there a way to feather the ends of threads?  In other words, where the threads start and end on any screw, they are feathered towards the OD of the shaft when they start and end - fade into the metal - don't know what they call that....

At the end of the screw, it's a "chamfer." If the threads don't run the full length of the screw, "runout" is where they blend into the unthreaded region. TCad Pro offers a Chamfer tool that takes care of the end of the screw quickly and painlessly (usually). To create a chamfer in Deluxe, you'd have to make a new object and 3D Subtract it from your threads. Runout is a lot more troublesome and not worth the bother, IMO.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 17, 2012, 07:22:39 AM
What would cause the Thread3D tool in Pro to gray out, after I make a screw?

Just made a screw it worked fine and now I can't access the tool....
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 17, 2012, 09:03:10 AM
What would cause the Thread3D tool in Pro to gray out, after I make a screw?

Just made a screw it worked fine and now I can't access the tool....

It's available only in Wireframe.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 17, 2012, 09:29:58 AM
Thanks :)
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 18, 2012, 04:31:14 PM
Can't understand what I am doing wrong here, I was 3d subtracting threads  made with thread3d  just fine before, to create id threaded bores, but now all of the sudden it's not working.  I even drew a simple cube, and 3d intersected some threads from a box and the hole is plugged.  I switched the threads from solid to TC surface...

I can see the subtracted threads in wireframe in the box, but not hidden line rendering...
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 18, 2012, 07:01:47 PM
Can't understand what I am doing wrong here, I was 3d subtracting threads  made with thread3d  just fine before, to create id threaded bores, but now all of the sudden it's not working.  I even drew a simple cube, and 3d intersected some threads from a box and the hole is plugged.  I switched the threads from solid to TC surface...

I can see the subtracted threads in wireframe in the box, but not hidden line rendering...

Lots of possibilities. Post the drawing.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 18, 2012, 07:50:56 PM
Here it is.  I started a new drawing/file from scratch.

U can see the threads in wireframe but not hidden line rendering.

Worked before don't know why it does not work now...
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 18, 2012, 08:28:49 PM
Here it is.  I started a new drawing/file from scratch.

U can see the threads in wireframe but not hidden line rendering.

Worked before don't know why it does not work now...

The object is corrupt, but I can't tell what caused the problem.

In any event, you're doing it the hard way. In Pro, have a look at the Hole tool and all of its options (accessible via its Properties dialog). Before using it, you need to set a Workplane on the face where the hole is to start and then place a Point object where you want the hole.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 06:10:10 AM
How could it not be on my menu?  I have the trial of Pro, and it's not there. Your menu has more options...
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 06:21:14 AM
On the problem, does TC need to be in Redsdk mode in order to 3d subtract a thread3d generated drawing with a TC surface?

Can't figure out why this worked fine a few days ago and now it does not work, even on a new drawing...I am thinking maybe I switdhed something on or off that that is causing the threads to not show but it seems strange that the threads would show fine in Wirefrane and not in hidden line
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 08:49:11 AM
I even just now tried making my own threads with the revolve tool as I did last week, and I am getting this error message when I try to 3d subtract them from a hole:

"The Resultant ACIS solid is degenerated.  The boolean operation is discarded."

I'm running out of options at this point it seems the only way to do it is to spin my own threads with revolve tool, insert the spins in holes and I won't 3d subtract them, just group the spins with the part.
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 10:38:11 AM
On the problem, does TC need to be in Redsdk mode in order to 3d subtract a thread3d generated drawing with a TC surface?

Can't figure out why this worked fine a few days ago and now it does not work, even on a new drawing...I am thinking maybe I switdhed something on or off that that is causing the threads to not show but it seems strange that the threads would show fine in Wirefrane and not in hidden line

No. But the entities involved in the subtract operation must be both Solids or both TC Surfaces.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 10:39:16 AM
I even just now tried making my own threads with the revolve tool as I did last week, and I am getting this error message when I try to 3d subtract them from a hole:

"The Resultant ACIS solid is degenerated.  The boolean operation is discarded."

I'm running out of options at this point it seems the only way to do it is to spin my own threads with revolve tool, insert the spins in holes and I won't 3d subtract them, just group the spins with the part.

That might well be the problem. Subtract from a solid object, not from a hole.

Henry H
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 10:56:19 AM
Tried that too did not work.

Are there any settings or preferences that would cause this?
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 11:01:16 AM
How could it not be on my menu?  I have the trial of Pro, and it's not there. Your menu has more options...

Not sure. See if it's available on your Drawing Tools toolbar. If it's not, go to Tools>Customize>Commands>All Commands, scroll down the list in the right-hand pane, and see if you can find it there. If you do, then drag the icon onto your Drawing Tools toolbar. If the tool is not listed in Tools>Customize, then maybe your trial version isn't sufficiently powerful. While the "Pro Platinum" edition contains this tool, perhaps lesser editions do not.

Henry H
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 12:00:17 PM
Tried that too did not work.

Are there any settings or preferences that would cause this?

Oops. I failed to note that you'd made the threads with the Revolve tool. Turns out that this operation is kinda finicky. To make it work, I had to take several non-obvious precautions: 1) Make the hole by subtracting a cylinder whose diameter is a tad larger than the minor diameter of the threads,  set its Number of approximation lines to 60, and check the "Smooth" option. 2) For the threads made with the Revolve tool, set the Spiral Pitch to a tad less than the height of a single revolution (i.e., make the coils overlap just a hair).

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 12:09:14 PM
How could it not be on my menu?  I have the trial of Pro, and it's not there. Your menu has more options...

My Insert menu also has 3D Object>Thread, which works on cylinders and in preexisting cylindrical holes in Solids.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 12:38:49 PM

My Insert menu also has 3D Object>Thread, which works on cylinders and in preexisting cylindrical holes in Solids.

Henry H

I can find thread3d but not thread.  I guess it does not come with TC Pro 19,
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 12:41:02 PM

Not sure. See if it's available on your Drawing Tools toolbar. If it's not, go to Tools>Customize>Commands>All Commands, scroll down the list in the right-hand pane, and see if you can find it there. If you do, then drag the icon onto your Drawing Tools toolbar. If the tool is not listed in Tools>Customize, then maybe your trial version isn't sufficiently powerful. While the "Pro Platinum" edition contains this tool, perhaps lesser editions do not.

Henry H

...could not find the "Hole" tool.

So if it's not on Tools>Customize>Commands>All Commands list - then I don't have it?

EDIT just checked the WIKI hole is only available in platinum.

WIKI does not have an entry for "Thread" tool though.
Post by: nadsab on December 19, 2012, 01:48:59 PM

For the threads made with the Revolve tool, set the Spiral Pitch to a tad less than the height of a single revolution (i.e., make the coils overlap just a hair).

Henry H

OK I'm trying to understand pitch - how does pitch relate to the height of a revolution?  Is the pitch the width of a thread?  In other words, if I have 32 threads per inch, then is the pitch itself is 1/32"?

How would this relate to revolution  height?
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 02:50:06 PM

For the threads made with the Revolve tool, set the Spiral Pitch to a tad less than the height of a single revolution (i.e., make the coils overlap just a hair).

Henry H

OK I'm trying to understand pitch - how does pitch relate to the height of a revolution?  Is the pitch the width of a thread?  In other words, if I have 32 threads per inch, then is the pitch itself is 1/32"?

How would this relate to revolution  height?

Right.

Henry H
Title: Re: Making my own threads question
Post by: Henry Hubich on December 19, 2012, 03:30:21 PM

Not sure. See if it's available on your Drawing Tools toolbar. If it's not, go to Tools>Customize>Commands>All Commands, scroll down the list in the right-hand pane, and see if you can find it there. If you do, then drag the icon onto your Drawing Tools toolbar. If the tool is not listed in Tools>Customize, then maybe your trial version isn't sufficiently powerful. While the "Pro Platinum" edition contains this tool, perhaps lesser editions do not.

Henry H

...could not find the "Hole" tool.

So if it's not on Tools>Customize>Commands>All Commands list - then I don't have it?

EDIT just checked the WIKI hole is only available in platinum.

WIKI does not have an entry for "Thread" tool though.

You might consider trying to find a good deal on v17.2 Platinum, which has those tools.

Henry H